Keywords
ontology, German Idealism, Hegel, Heidegger, Pippin, Befindlichkeit, mattering, the matter of mattering
Abstract
One individual’s culmination is another’s new beginning and yet another’s abyss. The abyss is nihilism. The challenge of such a Big Idea as The Culmination (the event, not the title of Robert Pippin’s book) is to weave the hermeneutic tapestry of the meaning of Being (Sein) as disclosed in poetry, aesthetics, and the life-world, while coaxing the lumbering Hegelian camel of German Idealism through the eye of the narrow needle of Dasein’s (Heideggerian) finitude. The world and entanglement are disclosed in a nondiscursive (preconceptual) manner as mattering. The way forward in philosophy lies through innovations in “mattering”—not a conceptual sense we humans make in relating to the world, but a nondiscursive distinction to which human beings are attuned. In a dialectical gesture worthy of Hegel, a reversal based in the phenomena themselves occurs as “discovery” is the original sense of truth and statement predication is derivative on it. Examples and counter-examples, provided by Dominque Janicaud. Heidegger’s ontological engagement with metaphysics as the culmination of German Idealism is elaborated in detail. Second, the implications for ontological education in a positive sense in a post metaphysical age are engaged and explored as “coming from nothing” and “learning to learn.”
Recommended Citation
Agosta, Lou
(2025)
"One Individual’s Culmination is Another’s Abyss: The Matter of Mattering,"
Turning Toward Being: The Journal of Ontological Inquiry in Education: Vol. 3:
Iss.
1, Article 2.
Available at:
https://rdw.rowan.edu/joie/vol3/iss1/2




